It’s official! The jury is in and the winners are…

Gatineau Park Visitor Centre

Winner

Student: Lyric Barnik
Faculty: Architecture Program
School:
University of Waterloo

Runner-up

Students: Jacob Drung and Hannah Carmichael
Faculty: Architecture Program
School: University of Waterloo

Honorable mention

Students: Grace Wilson and Alexander Rickert
Faculty: Architecture Program
Faculty advisor: Shannon Bassett
School: Laurentian University

Sussex Courtyards

Winner

Students: Yuan Li, Siqing Hu and Yuxin Ti
Faculty: Architecture, Landscape and Design
Faculty advisor: Mark Sterling
School:
University of Toronto

Runner-up

Students: Liane Werdina (Ryerson University, Architectural Science), Vivian Kinuthia (Ryerson University, Architectural Science) and Maro Austin-Igbuku (University of Waterloo, Planning)
Faculty: Architectural Science and Planning
School:
Ryerson University and University of Waterloo

The NCC would like to thank all those who participated in the 2020 challenge.

Introduction

Urban Design Challenge 2020 is a competition that invites students from across the country to come up with design concepts for important sites in Canada’s Capital Region. The competition is organized by the National Capital Commission (NCC), the federal Crown corporation dedicated to ensuring that Canada’s Capital is a dynamic and inspiring source of pride for all Canadians, and building a legacy for generations to come.

Challenge

The NCC is challenging students to propose innovative planning and design ideas for two important destinations in the Capital Region.

  • SITE 1: The Sussex Courtyards (Ottawa, Ontario) 
    OR
  • SITE 2: The Gatineau Park Visitor Centre (Chelsea, Quebec)

Participants in the Urban Design Challenge are required to focus their ideas on one of the two sites.

Refer to the design brief for additional information about the two subject sites.

Jury and Evaluation Criteria #

A jury of interdisciplinary planning, design and site management professionals will review the submissions and select competition winners. A winning submission will provide bold design concepts that consider the following:

  • site context
  • leading sustainability elements
  • environmental and ecological features
  • public access
  • four-season use
  • tourism and recreational opportunities
  • current master plans and policies.


Awards

There will be one winning project for each site. The first-place award for each site is $750.

(The jury may determine runners-up and honourable mention awards as well. There are no monetary prizes associated with these awards.)

The winning teams will be invited to present their ideas at a special awards presentation session of the NCC’s Urbanism Lab in the fall of 2020. Travel and accommodation expenses for the two winning teams will be covered (see details that follow under Terms of Reference, Eligibility, to learn about the rules).


Partner

Thanks to VIA Rail, winning teams will present their ideas in Ottawa in the fall of 2020.

VIA Rail is the official transportation service provider for this year’s Student Ideas Competition for Canada’s Capital.

Context

Role of the NCC

The NCC is the federal Crown corporation dedicated to ensuring that Canada’s Capital is a dynamic and inspiring source of pride for all Canadians, and a legacy for generations to come. The NCC is responsible for the long-term planning of the national capital, and is the approval authority for federal lands and buildings. In addition to its planning and approval roles, the NCC is also the steward and manager of many important properties throughout the Capital, including historic buildings and places, public spaces, parks, squares, parkways, shorelines and green spaces.

Capital planning

At the apex of the Capital Planning Framework stands the Plan for Canada’s Capital, 2017–2067. This plan lays out a blueprint for the evolution of federal lands in Canada’s Capital Region over a 50-year horizon; it is the NCC’s pre-eminent planning document.

The Capital Planning Framework also includes sector plans, which further refine the themes, goals, policies and strategies for particular geographic areas. Canada’s Capital Core Area Sector Plan guides decision making and informs future planning initiatives for the heart of the National Capital Region, and the Gatineau Park Master Plan guides the planning, management and activities permitted with the boundaries of Gatineau Park.

Study Areas


Site 1 : Sussex Courtyards

The Sussex Courtyards are important public spaces within the historic ByWard Market area in downtown Ottawa.

Site 2 : Gatineau Park Visitor Centre

The Visitor Centre is the primary arrival and information point for park visitors, as well as the administrative and operational hub for NCC staff.


Terms of reference

The competition is open to any students who are currently enrolled in a design-focused program at an accredited educational institution in Canada. The maximum number of participants per team is three.

The NCC encourages students to form interdisciplinary teams. Proposals should consider aspects of urban planning, site design, architecture and landscape design. A diverse team of complementary skills is likely to result in a more successful submission.

For complete rules and regulations, click here.

There is no registration fee to participate in the Urban Design Challenge. However, participants are required to register and to receive a team number in order to ensure that the submissions remain anonymous throughout the evaluation process. One registration is required per project submitted.

Participants may register on the competition website: ncc-ccn.gc.ca/2020-challenge. By registering, participants agree to all competition terms and conditions. Registration will remain open until February 14, 2020.

General

1. Is there a budget that our proposals should work within? If there is not an exact budget, should the project be idealistic or realistic?

There is no specific budget. Plans should definitely be aspirational, but keep in mind that proposals should be feasible.

2. If there is interest in some small to medium-sized infrastructure, what level of detail would be best for architectural elements?

We are interested in infrastructure that reflects the objectives of the various plans that are relevant to your chosen site. Regarding level of detail, we want conceptual drawings, not construction drawings, for architectural elements. You may provide information in plan, elevations, sections and pedestrian eye-level views.

3. Are we allowed to change our site selection?

Each team can make 1 change to their site selection before February 28, 2020. You must inform the NCC of any change by emailing stanley.leinwand@ncc-ccn.ca or gregory.kerr@ncc-ccn.ca. After that date, no changes are permitted.

4. Is there a preferred citation style (e.g. APA) for any references used in our 500-word description? How should we cite existing products or services that we might want to use in our design?

There is no preferred citation style. That being said, we ask that teams be consistent and use a single citation style throughout.

5. It seems like all the files provided are AutoCAD files and do not have any spatial reference. Do you have any other files that we can use that would fix this issue?

The data should all be in NAD 83 MTM Zone 9. If you encounter any issues, please email us.

6. Do you have any data on hydrology, slope, typology or species at risk?

All available GIS data is in the OneDrive file. We do not have any mapping of the sewers beneath the two sites. The best documents to consult regarding species at risk are the official plans that pertain to the study area.

7. Are there 3-D models of the sites?

We don’t have any compiled 3-D models for these sites.

Gatineau Park

1. Can the proposal for the site extend beyond the study area?

No, the original boundaries defined in the site documentation need to be respected. There are reasons why the study area was selected (including, but not limited to, environment, logistics, zoning and other factors). Going outside the study area would create multiple challenges. To maintain clarity and a fair playing field for all teams, we are asking all teams to stay within the boundaries presented.

Sussex Courtyards

1. Who owns the spaces between the courtyards (e.g. streets, patios) that aren’t highlighted in the design brief? Can we design for these spaces in our proposal, too?

The municipal streets and sidewalks between the courtyards are part of the public domain. If you and your team would like your proposal to include connective strategies that use these spaces, you may include them.

2. Are we able to design the space as a blank canvas, or are there immovable elements (e.g. sculptures, existing signage, trees, lighting)?

You can design it as a blank canvas.

3. Do we have to design for all five courtyards, or are we supposed to choose one?

The challenge for the Sussex Courtyards is to look at all five of the courtyards in a holistic way — not to choose only one. Design concepts for each courtyard should be tailored to the specific needs and uses of that courtyard. However, the design must look at all of the courtyards as a unit, and how they do the following:

  • Support and enhance the unique heritage character of the area
  • Improve connections, visibility and relationship to the surrounding urban context of the ByWard Market
  • Create new public and commercial amenities that will animate the site, year-round, both during the daytime and into the evenings
  • Respect the diverse, mixed-use residential neighbourhood of the ByWard Market
  • Attract a critical mass of potential customers, and generate economic returns
  • Improve the safety, accessibility, maintenance and operating conditions of the courtyards

Questions regarding the competition will be accepted until February 28, 2020. Questions should be emailed to: stanley.leinwand@ncc-ccn.ca or gregory.kerr@ncc-ccn.ca. All emails sent should include “Student Competition 2020” in the subject line. Answers to all questions will be posted on the competition website: ncc-ccn.gc.ca/2020-challenge.

Submissions may be prepared in either of Canada’s two official languages (English and French). The deadline for competition submissions is 11:59 pm, Eastern Daylight Time, on May 1, 2020. All submissions will be made via the NCC’s FTP site; further details will be provided to participants after registration. No hard copies of materials will be accepted.

The Urban Design Challenge is an anonymous competition. No names or identifying symbols of participants shall appear on submitted material or in filenames.

Submissions should consist of the following elements:

  • Up to two 60.96-cm x 91.44-cm (24-in. x 36-in.) boards in PDF format. The filenames should include the registration number (e.g. “Board_12345”). All drawings and architectural scales should be expressed in metric.
  • A written statement not exceeding 500 words explaining the ideas. The file should be in .txt or Word format. The filename should include the registration number (e.g. “Written_12345”).
  • A document with contact information for the participating individual/team. The document should include the project title, participant name(s) and email address for primary contact. The filename should include the registration number (e.g. “ID_12345”). The sources of any third-party material incorporated in the entry must also be included.

    Each participant shall retain ownership of the copyright associated with the entries submitted.

    By submitting an entry, each participant grants the NCC a non-exclusive perpetual licence to use, reproduce, publish, modify, incorporate into other work, distribute and promote, in whole or in part, the materials submitted by the participant for any non-commercial or commercial purpose, in any format whatsoever, including print, digital publication, audio, video and all other media (whether now known or later developed), in any form, without territorial limits and without attribution.

    By submitting an entry, participants warrant that their entry is original. See the design contest rules and regulations for further information. 


    December 12, 2019Competition launches
    February 14, 2020Last day for registration
    February 28, 2020Last day to send questions
    May 1, 2020Submissions due
    May 2020Jury consideration
    End of May 2020Winners will be contacted
    June 1, 2020Winners will be publicly announced

    Fall 2020: to be confirmed

    Awards presentation

    Rules and regulations

    Urban Design Challenge 2020

    General

    National Capital Commission. The Plan for Canada’s Capital, 2017–2067.

    National Capital Commission. Sustainable Development Strategy, 2018–2023.

    Site 1: Sussex Courtyards

    National Capital Commission website


    http://ncc-ccn.gc.ca/projects/sussex-courtyards

    http://ncc-ccn.gc.ca/blog/a-legacy-to-build-on

    National Capital Commission. Canada’s Capital Core Area Sector Plan.

    National Capital Commission. Capital Illumination Plan, 2017–2027.

    City of Ottawa: GeoOttawa mapping tool.

    http://maps.ottawa.ca/geoottawa/

    City of Ottawa. Official Plan.

    https://ottawa.ca/en/planning-development-and-construction/official-plan-and-master-plans/official-plan

    City of Ottawa. Zoning By-law No. 2008-250.

    https://ottawa.ca/en/living-ottawa/laws-licences-and-permits/laws/law-z/planning-development-and-construction/maps-and-zoning/zoning-law-no-2008-250

    City of Ottawa. Pedestrian Plan.

    https://ottawa.ca/en/planning-development-and-construction/official-plan-and-master-plans#ottawa-pedestrian-plan

    City of Ottawa. ByWard Market Public Realm Plan.

    https://ottawa.ca/en/city-hall/public-engagement/projects/byward-market-public-realm-plan

    Parks Canada website, Federal Heritage Buildings Review Office (FHBRO)

    https://www.pc.gc.ca/en/culture/beefp-fhbro

    Documentation Repository:

    • Project for Public Spaces for the City of Ottawa. Strengthening the Future of the ByWard Market. . In English only.
    • Commonwealth Resource Management for the National Capital Commission. Cultural Heritage Impact Statement for the Proposed Redevelopment of 7 Clarence Street, ByWard Market, Ottawa, Ontario,February 2014. In English only.
    • Michael Newton, NCC historian.Lowertown Ottawa, Volume 1 (1826–1854) and Volume 2 (1894–1900). In English only.
    • Heritage Dossier: Sussex Courtyards, Spring 2018. In English only.
    • du Toit Allsopp Hillier. Sussex Heritage Courtyards Urban Design Study , February 2004. In English only.


    Site 2: Gatineau Park Visitor Centre


    National Capital Commission website

    http://ncc-ccn.gc.ca/places/gatineau-park

    http://ncc-ccn.gc.ca/places/gatineau-park-visitor-information

    National Capital Commission. Gatineau Park Master Plan, 2005.

    Municipality of Chelsea. Special Planning Program and Concordance By-laws, November 2011. English version of the document provided as a courtesy. In the event of a discrepancy, the French text will prevail.

    https://www.chelsea.ca/application/files/2115/5682/7902/8_-_635-05_appendix_5_anglais.pdf

    Ministère des Affaires municipales et de l’Habitation du Québec. Schéma d'aménagement et de développement d'une municipalité régionale de comté (MRC). In French only.

    www.mamh.gouv.qc.ca/amenagement-du-territoire/

    Documentation Repository:

    • National Capital Commission. Entrances to Gatineau Park, November 2009 (final report).
    • National Capital Commission. Statement of Requirements, Gatineau Park Visitor Centre.
    • Bryden Martel Architect Inc., for the National Capital Commission. Gatineau Park Visitor Centre, Functional Program and Location Considerations, June 18, 2012.